A passage from Chapter 31 of White
Noise reminded me of our in-class discussion of the most photographed barn in
America. While the family sits in their
car, eating dinner, Denise discusses how mountains are always north of
cities. DeLillo wrote, “’Mountains are
always upstate,’ Denise told her. ‘This way the snow melts as planned in the
spring and flows downhill to the reservoirs near the cities, which are kept
which are kept in the lower end of the state for exactly this reason.’” This quote is significant because it
demonstrates the way in which humans are disconnected from their
environment. This is highlighted by the
use of the word “planned” as though humans had planned the environment rather
than reacting to it. In class we talked
about how the aura of the barn is created by the sign that marks its importance
and the people who stop to photograph it rather than anything special about the
barn itself. Although it is a different
context, this is paralleled by Denise’s understanding of the role of mountains
in city life. Denise does not understand
cites as being built around water supply, instead, she believes that the
mountains arrange themselves around the city.
While this can be understood as simply as a child’s misunderstanding,
Jack finds himself compelled by Denise’s explanation. He wonders for a moment whether she is
right. His instincts push him in the
other direction but he cannot think of any evidence to disprove her
hypothesis. This speaks to the type of
world that they live in. They exist in a
realm of reproductions which disconnects them from any process of original production. They lack the sense to tell them that people
form cities in locations where they have access to resources. DeLillo paints a picture of a family where
they are so disconnected that they cannot figure out that the mountains are
north of the city because people built the city south of the mountains. This echoes DeLillo’s mention of the most
photographed barn because they are the result of the same condition. People photograph the barn because other
people photograph the barn. People live
south of the mountains because other people live south of the mountains. In the world that DeLillo creates, there is
an eerie loss of the understanding of this somewhat simple concept. DeLillo instead connects his characters to commodities
and other effects of the commercialized world known as white noise.
I think this topic is fascinating, but I'd like to see you work especially with Jack's reaction. You might also slightly adjust the phrasing of the analysis - the phrase "which are kept on the lower end" grammatically refers to cities - so I'm not quite getting the connection between the sentence itself and your reading. That's not to say that I don't think your reading is plausible - in fact, I think it is - and would be even stronger with an account of Jack's response. Regardless, the topic of environment/nature and the "loss of understanding" is intriguing.
ReplyDelete